HOME

PANTRY HOW TO HOW BAKING WORKS BAKING TERMS SEARCH
bread cakes candy chocolate cookies custard
decorating frozen healthy pastry pies quick breads

ASK SARAH FORUM & RECIPES
Login Not a Member? Register

 

Cookies 101: Tips

Page 2

To Pages
1 2 3

To Cookies 101

What Went Wrong ?

Chocolate Chip Cookie Information

Cookie Making Tools & Cookie Sheet Choices

The Complete Cookie Storage Guide

How to Decorate Cookies

An Old-Fashioned Cookie Swap

Step-by-Step Cookie Baking & Decorating Tips with Photos.

Cookie dough usually contains perishable items such as eggs. For this reason, keep cookie dough refrigerated if not using. Discard any that has been unrefrigerated for more than two hours.

General pointers for successful cookies: 

TIP #1: When baking cookies, use light-colored, NON-insulated cookie sheets. Always bake with an oven thermometer. Preheat the oven and prepare the cookie sheets.

Q: Can I eat raw cookie dough? A:  I do not recommend it. Cookie dough usually contains perishable items which spoil easily. Also, consuming the raw eggs in them carry a risk of your getting salmonella. 

Most cookies bake at about 350 degrees F, considered a "medium" oven temperature. 

Cookies bake nicely and brown more evenly, but also bake faster in a convection oven. Lower the temperature by 25 to 50 degrees than the recipe states when going from conventional oven to convection

ALWAYS preheat your oven for about 20 minutes or until done before baking your cookies. Cookies, as all baking recipes, are best baked in a well-preheated oven.. 

Preheat the oven and use an oven thermometer to monitor an accurate temperature. (It can be purchased from the grocery store). Hang it on the middle rack. If it runs hot, the cookies will burn, if too low, they'll take longer to bake and melt before they hold their shape. Adjust the oven's heat, if necessary, to get the right temperature. 

TIP #2: Have all ingredients at room temperature, prepare and measure them accurately:

How to get room temperature butter !! 

How to get room temperature eggs !!

Read through the recipe and make sure you have all ingredients on hand. (Make adjustments when baking at high altitudes.) 

Have all ingredients at room temperature, especially butter and eggs, unless specified otherwise. Cold, hard butter will not cream as easily when you incorporate it with the sugar resulting in flat, so-so cookies. 

Prepare any ingredients used in the recipe: when adding dried fruit like raisins or currants to the dough, plump them first to make sure they are soft, not hard and shriveled. Prepare coconut, chopped chocolate, etc. Toast and cool any chopped nuts or coconut before using. 

How to measure ingredients !!

It is important to measure carefully, as tiny drops of moisture cause a cookie to spread or puff or too much flour makes a cookie dry and flavorless. If a recipe calls for light or dark brown sugar be sure you firmly pack it into the measuring cup for an accurate measurement. 

TIP #3:  DO NOT OVERMIX the ingredients:   

An important step in cookie baking, that is often overlooked, is to properly cream the stick butter and crystalline sugar (white and brown sugar) together. Creaming  is done to beat air in the dough, so necessary for a puffy cookie. If this step is overdone, the creamed butter loses air; the cookies will puff up in the oven and then fall. If underdone, there isn't enough air beaten into the dough and they won't puff up in the first place. This is ONE of the reasons why chocolate chip cookies or any cookie can turn out flat.  

Overmixing the flour with the liquid ingredients, will cause the cookie to be tough and flavorless. The more wheat flour is moistened and stirred, the more gluten strands form an elastic network that strengthens as you mix. 

While mixing the cookie dough or batter, do not allow it to become too warm. If the dough seems sticky, refrigerate it rather than add more flour. Excessive flour is the main culprit in producing hard, dry cookies.  

Q: When making stiff cookie dough, does it matter if you use the paddle attachment or the whisk attachment to a mixer?
A: Yes. I use the paddle attachment, unless the recipe specifies otherwise. Stiff dough is hard on your whisk attachment when mixing it and you'll risk bending the wires. Whisk attachments also aerate the cookie dough too much. 

Cookies are essentially made by several methods of mixing, the first one being the most commonly used. 

1. The cake method (creaming process). Be sure to do this thoroughly: work the butter or other shortening against the side of the bowl until it is smooth and softened, then incorporate the sugar, blending until the mixture is fluffy. 

2. The quickbread / muffin method: quickly combing wet and dry ingredients together; and then gingerly combining together. 

3. The pastry method: the fat is cut into the flour. Once the flour is added, the dough should be mixed well, but not beaten at length for this will toughen the cookies. 

TIP #4: Form the cookie dough on the cookie sheet(s). THINK COLD.

I have found that the best cookie sheets are the ones that are: Non-insulated, shiny aluminum pans (light in color, not dark) without sides, preferably non-stick. These pans bake cookies the best and evenly: the cookies were lightly and evenly browned around its edges, a hint of browning on top, experienced less spread and baked the fastest. 

If you have dark pans, they absorb more heat than shiny, aluminum ones, and can easily cause burned cookie bottoms - you may want to reduce the temperature by 25 degrees F.

Don't grease your pans. Instead, use parchment paper to line them or spray pans with vegetable oil spray. If done with butter, it burns under high heat, perhaps causing the cookie bottoms to burn underneath.

When a cookie sheet comes straight from the oven, remove the baked cookies from it, clean it by scraping off the stuck on crumbs with the side of a metal spatula, and then cool it completely before using it again for the next batch. Any cookie dough will spread immediately and may connect together when placed on a warm cookie sheet because the fat in it melts. The ones with butter or margarine will spread more than those made with shortening.

A half-batch of cookies on a full sheet will absorb too much heat and are more susceptible to burning. It's better to spread the half batch evenly over the cookie sheet before baking. 

Cookies come in different shapes and sizes. Cookie dough can be spooned, dropped, rolled and cut out, molded, pressed from a cookie gun and more. (Cookie types) 

Note: Keep the formed dough pieces the same size and thickness on the cookie sheet. Doing so produces uniform shaped cookies that are evenly baked, preventing some from being over- or under-done. 

1. Drop cookies: Drop cookies are made from dough pushed from a rounded teaspoonful onto a a cool cookie sheet. They are the easiest type to make. Drop cookies usually spread as they bake because of their ingredients, so be sure to allow about 2 inches between mounds of dough.

2. Rolled & cookie cutter cookies: Rolled cookies are made from dough that is chilled and then rolled on a countertop dusted with as little flour possible. (Silpat mats that don't require a sprinkling of flour on them, work well). Shapes are cut from it, usually with cookie cutters. 

A half-batch of cookies on a full sheet will absorb too much heat and are more susceptible to burning. It's better to spread the half batch evenly over the cookie sheet before baking. 

After you mix the cookie dough, most recipes require refrigeration. This firms up the dough so it rolls and cuts more easily and won't loose it's shape as much when baked. Pat the dough into a large, 1-inch thick rectangle and wrap it in plastic wrap. Refrigerate the dough, 20 minutes to an hour, preferably overnight. When you are ready to roll it, the dough will be somewhat  flat, cold throughout and easier to handle.   

Use a large rolling pin to roll the cookie dough; it will keep the pressure even, which results in the same thickness throughout. Roll it to the recommended thickness because baking times and the finished texture of crisp or soft, are directly related. The thinner the dough, the more delicate and crisp the cookie. Cut-out cookies destined for hanging on the Christmas tree should be kept fairly thick so they don't break. Poke a hole for string into the unbaked cookie with the end of a drinking straw.

To prevent very large cut cookies from losing their shape, roll dough directly onto cookie sheet. Cut all your cookies and remove excess dough. 

Before cutting cookies, dip the cookie cutters half way into flour (knocking off any excess) or vegetable oil so that the edges won’t stick while cutting. 

Cut from the dough, from the center out, keeping the cookies close together. After cutting, scraps from rolling may be gathered, chilled, and rerolled, although cookies cut from them will not be quite as tender as those from the initial rolling. Don't overwork the dough scraps.

After cutting or shaping cookies, put them on prepared cookie sheets with the help of a flat spatula and slip them into the freezer for a few minutes to help them hold their shape when they are baked.  

Cut out as many cookies as possible, as re-rolled dough scraps can yield tough cookies -- the more the dough is handled, the tougher the cookie. Dip cutters half-way into flour each time you cut. I recently read that a baker dipped their cookie cutter in vegetable oil, instead of flour. I have never tried it; let me know if you do. 

3. Icebox Cookie Dough (in a log shape): Some cookies are cut from a cookie dough log. Often, the cookie log will flatten on one side as you cut. For a round cookie shape, make sure that the dough log is very cold, and every four to six slices, turn the dough log a quarter turn, to help maintain its shape. 

I have used my sugar cookie recipe to make "cakes" by baking them in a pan and then turning out and decorating.  Just don't make them too thick and bake at 325-degrees so the cookie dough bakes through in the middle. 

The other thing I do is to cut cookie dough with WAXED dental floss. (Flavored dental floss can be used because it does not leave a taste!!) You need a long lengths because you need to wrap around your fingers, as well as making sure the exposed length is a little longer than the circumference of the dough. Please note that as soon as the floss gets sticky, it doesn't work.

4. Bar cookies are generally made from a batter that is spread in a pan, then baked, cooled, and often stored right in the pan. In this way they are the simplest of cookies, requiring little handling.

5. Molded cookies are made from a stiff dough that is formed by hand into little balls, crescents, canes, and other shapes, or forced through a cookie press. Handle the dough as little as possible and keep it chilled.

This is Page 2
To Pages
1 2 3
up arrowup arrow

HOME

PANTRY HOW TO HOW BAKING WORKS BAKING TERMS BAKING TIPS
bread cakes candy chocolate cookies custard
decorating frozen healthy pastry pies quick breads

ASK SARAH FORUM & RECIPES
Login Not a Member? Register

© baking911.com, Inc., 2000- 2008. Founded October, 2000. All Rights Reserved. All material on baking911.com's web pages is the express opinion of its authors. baking911.com is not responsible for any direct, incidental, consequential, indirect or punitive damages arising out of its pages or those accessed through this Site. baking 911 is a registered trademark and "bake like a pro" is a trademark of Sarah Phillips
~ Order my cookbooks ~ Baking 9-1-1 and The Healthy Oven Baking Book  ~ Recipe Fixes